Psych: Mind Over Magic Page 17

  “That.”

  Jessica Higgenbotham stood by her car, waiting as a tall, handsome man in a polo shirt and khaki shorts walked up to her. She looked up as he clasped his hands on her bare shoulders and leaned down for a quick kiss.

  “Is that what this is all about?” Gus said. “Are they having an affair?”

  “Is who having an affair?” Shawn said.

  “I don’t know.” Gus realized he had absolutely no idea whom they had been following or whom she was meeting.

  “And even if who is having an affair, who is who having an affair with?”

  “What?”

  “Exactly,” Shawn said. “So let’s stop spreading those terrible rumors. You should be ashamed of yourself.”

  Shawn jumped out of the car and walked over to Jessica Higgenbotham and the tall man. Gus locked his car door, then ran to catch up to him.

  “We didn’t have a chance to finish our conversation,” Shawn said. “And I wanted to give you a chance to put things right before your all-important interview.”

  When Gus was in second grade, one of the other children had gotten overexcited toward the climax of a particularly intense match of tag and had peed in his pants. That was the last time he could remember seeing a look of disgust as intense as the one on Jessica Higgenbotham’s face.

  “Who’s this, honey?” the tall man said, clearly making an effort to stay pleasant until all the facts were in.

  “He says he’s the chef at some restaurant I’ve never heard of,” Jessica said. “And this other guy is his dishwasher. They showed up at our house and started making ridiculous charges about missing silverware or something.”

  “And they followed you here?”

  “Apparently,” she said.

  The tall man ran his gaze over Shawn and Gus slowly. “I don’t understand why you’re harassing my wife,” he said in an amiable tone that still managed to convey an undercurrent of menace. “But if your camera crew doesn’t appear in two minutes to prove that this is some kind of reality-prank-show gag, I’m going to have to ask club security to hold you until the police arrive.”

  The tall man took his wife by the elbow and steered her toward the clubhouse.

  “I don’t have a camera crew,” Shawn said. “But I will admit I’m not really a chef.”

  Shawn and Gus waited for an anxious second. If she kept walking, which everybody in the parking lot knew she should, they would lose their chance to question her. But Shawn’s behavior was too outrageous for her to let it go. She pulled her elbow away from her husband’s grip and wheeled around on them.

  “Then who the hell are you?” she snapped.

  “My name, as I told you, is Shawn Spencer,” Shawn said calmly. “I run a little private detective agency in town. But I am also the official background investigator for the Little Hills Country Club.”

  “And who’s this guy?” Jessica said with a glance toward Gus. “Your henchman?”

  “No, actually he really is my chief dishwasher,” Shawn said. “You’d be amazed at how much china gets dirty in this job.”

  “My name is David Higgenbotham, and I don’t see you as being the official anything for the Little Hills Country Club,” the tall man said, “because then you would know that denim is not allowed anywhere on club grounds.”

  “My position forces me to work undercover, Mr. Higgenbotham,” Shawn said. “As distasteful as it is to me, sometimes that even means wearing denim on the grounds. Now, I have a few questions for your wife.”

  “It’s a little late,” the tall man said. “Jessica’s final interview starts in five minutes.”

  “And that interview can last half an hour or half a day,” Shawn said. “It’s really up to you at this point. I suppose if it’s not important to you that you two are admitted, we have nothing left to say to each other.”

  The Higgenbothams exchanged a look that told Shawn everything he needed to know. Well, almost everything. The rest he learned when he took a closer look at David and saw. Saw the shield in place of a rearing pony on the polo shirt, with a knit fish between two books across its top. Saw the tiny white scars on his hands.

  “You’ve got two minutes,” David Higgenbotham said.

  “Then I’ll skip the boring stuff you know about,” Shawn said. “Like the years the two of you spent touring with a vaudeville revival troupe, her as a one-woman freak show and you as the knife thrower.”

  This was the moment Gus was waiting for—when they laughed in Shawn’s face. Because there was simply no way Jessica Higgenbotham was the same tattooed woman they’d seen the other night. And David? He looked as if he’d been bred in a special pen somewhere in a compound on Kennebunkport or Martha’s Vineyard. His anticipation of seeing Shawn acknowledge that he was wrong and Gus was right would almost be worth all the time they’d wasted on these two.

  But David Higgenbotham didn’t laugh in Shawn’s face. He didn’t turn up his nose in disgust or wrinkle his brow in confusion.

  “The admissions committee knows all about our past,” David said. “We were completely up-front about it. And they don’t have a problem with it. As they explained, they’re all past fifty, which means their late teen and early-adult years were in the 1960s. They know all about youthful indiscretion.”

  Gus couldn’t believe what he was hearing. Or, more accurately, what he was seeing. Or even more accurately, what he wasn’t seeing. He was staring at Jessica’s arms and seeing nothing but smooth, tanned, beautiful skin.

  “And when you gave up performing, you got your MBA at Wharton, and you’ve been a respectable member of society ever since,” Shawn said.

  “If you consider CFO of the Central Coast’s largest telecommunications start-up to be respectable,” David said. “Now, what’s this all about?”

  “We just need to confirm that neither of you has been performing lately,” Shawn said. “There have been rumors of a New Vaudeville revival, and if you’re thinking of being part of it, you can’t be part of us.”

  “Absolutely not,” David said. “We made a pact when we moved into the straight world that this is where we would live forever. And to prove that, we both went through endless hours of incredible pain having our tattoos removed. Isn’t that right, honey?”

  Jessica’s face had gone pale. Oddly, the rest of her was the same golden tan it always had been. “Yes,” she said. “Incredible.”

  “So if that’s all you have for us, it’s time for my wife’s interview,” David said.

  “Absolutely,” Shawn said. “Sorry to waste your time.”

  Gus couldn’t believe it. First Shawn had uncovered her identity, and now he was letting her walk away without even questioning her. He couldn’t let that stand.

  “But we saw you at the Fortress of Magic the other night,” Gus said. “You remember, the night P’tol P’kah disappeared.”

  “That’s ridiculous,” Jessica said.

  “Outrageous,” David said.

  “I knew I should never have taken you off plate duty,” Shawn said. “Apologize to these good people.”

  Gus glared at Shawn, but Shawn glared back even harder—and then topped it off with a full frontal tsk tsk. He turned back to the Higgenbothams.

  “Please allow me to apologize for my dishwasher,” Shawn said. “On behalf of the entire Little Hills Country Club, on whose hallowed ground he will never be allowed to tread again.”

  Shawn held out a hand to David, who took it and gave it a hearty shake. Then he turned to Jessica. She reluctantly extended a hand to him, and he took it in both of his. As he did, Gus heard a squooshing sound and saw Jessica staring at Shawn with a look of pure bafflement.

  “I am so sorry,” Shawn said as he pulled back his hands, revealing the squort of orange goo he’d squished onto the back of her hand. “I forgot I was holding that. Please, let me help get it off.”

  Before she could pull her hand away, Shawn was rubbing at the spot with the tail of his untucked flannel shirt. Wherever he rubbed, Gus
could see brightly colored snakes emerging like chicks out of their eggs. With a jolt, Gus realized that what Shawn had oozed onto her hand was not orange goo but Orange Goo, the grease remover used in mechanics’ shops. Apparently it was just as efficient in removing spray-on tan as it was on motor oil. That’s why he’d made Gus drive him down to the cart repair bay.

  Jessica realized it at the same time Gus did. She snatched her hand away and buried it deep inside her purse. Her face, which had gone white just moments before, flared red with rage. And yet her arms were still the same golden shade of tan.

  “I’m sorry, did I hurt you?” Shawn said. “Let me see that.”

  He reached for her hand, but she shoved it deeper into her purse.

  “Is everything okay, honey?” David’s voice quavered with concern. It was hard for Gus to imagine this soft, sweet soul hurling knives in a traveling carnival.

  “I’m fine,” she said firmly. “Why don’t you go ahead and let the committee know I’ll be right in. I’ll just clear up any loose ends with these gentlemen.”

  David gave her a questioning look, then turned and trotted toward the clubhouse.

  “Who the hell are you and what do you want?” she hissed at Shawn as soon as David was out of earshot.

  “Just who we said we are,” Shawn said.

  “Except for me being a dishwasher,” Gus added. “I also work for Psych Investigations.”

  “Oh, and that thing about working for the country club,” Shawn said. “We don’t do that.”

  “What a shock,” Jessica said. “So what is your main line of work? Blackmail? Extortion? Or just ruining innocent people who’ve never hurt you?”

  “We saw you at the Fortress of Magic,” Gus said. “And we have you on tape working as a cocktail waitress so you could get close to P’tol P’kah. So I’m not sure how innocent that makes you.”

  “Me?” She spit out the word like a curse. “I’m not innocent. I’m a born carny. But David. He’s the real thing. All he wants is for us to be members here. And you’ve come along to ruin it.”

  Shawn stared off into the distance, then pressed his fingertips to his forehead. “I see a young woman, touring the country, performing acts that fascinate and repel. And in the crowd, a sweet young man who comes to every performance. One day he—”

  “Knock off the psychic crap, will you?” she snapped. “I’m sure I’m an open book to all your really special magical powers. So yes, David came from a good family. They were shocked when he told them he was dropping out of college because he’d fallen in love with, well, me. I even tried to talk him out of it, but he insisted on joining the troupe. He started off as a knife thrower, but when the full extent of his talent became known, we started calling him the Amazing Bleeding Man.”

  “And then you fell in love with him,” Shawn said. “So much so that you agreed to give up performing so that his family would accept you. You even had your tattoos removed.”

  “They seem to have grown back, though,” Gus said.

  “I couldn’t do it,” Jessica said. “As much as I loved him—love him—the stage was in my blood. So I told a couple of little white lies.”

  “And a lot of big tan ones,” Shawn said.

  “And everybody’s happy,” Jessica said. “We’ve got the life David’s always dreamed of, complete with a set of anecdotes that will conquer any cocktail party, and I’ve got a couple of hobbies he doesn’t have to know about.”

  “He didn’t notice you were in Vegas three or four nights a week?” Gus said.

  “He travels a lot for his job,” Jessica said. “No one knew.”

  “Except for one chubby guy in a three-piece suit and a bowler hat,” Shawn said. “And a drink in his face.”

  “I don’t know what you’re talking about,” Jessica said.

  “It’s on tape, too,” Gus said. “And I’m sure the police would like to know why you denied having ever seen him before he showed up floating in a tank of water.”

  “I doubt they’d be able to charge you with his murder, though,” Shawn said. “They’d probably even have to drop the obstruction of justice charges after a thorough investigation. And I’m sure the membership committee here would be proud to know that at least one of their new members had been completely cleared of any felonious actions.”

  Jessica looked like one of her knives had slipped clear through the eyeball and penetrated her frontal lobe. “I didn’t kill him,” she said.

  “We know you didn’t,” Shawn said, “because whoever did must have known the secret of the Dissolving Man. And since you’re joining a country club instead of booking a Vegas showroom, you don’t.”

  “We just need to know what he said to you that night,” Gus said.

  “If I tell you, will you promise to leave David out of it?”

  “We’ll do our best,” Shawn said.

  She sighed heavily. “I used to see him there on nights when I waitressed. There was always something creepy about him—and I’m used to people who pay money to watch me stick knives in my eyeballs. That night as I was passing by, he grabbed my arm and started telling me how sexy I was, and how he wanted to see if my tattoos covered my entire body.”

  “Bet you’d never heard that one before,” Shawn said.

  “Only from every man I’d ever met before I discovered the wonders of spray-on tan,” she said. “I tried to pull away, but he squeezed harder. So I threw the drink in his face, which I hated to do, because they charge us for that. And then he threatened me—and David.”

  “He knew you were married?” Gus said.

  “He knew who I was married to,” she said. “He knew everything about me. My real name, David’s family, David’s business.”

  “How?” Shawn said.

  “He said he worked for the government.” Jessica was near tears remembering it. “He worked for the government, and if I didn’t do exactly what he wanted me to, he’d make sure the next cocktail I served would be a Mojito at Guantanamo Bay.”

  Chapter Eighteen

  Gus’ mind reeled. The dead man floating in the magician’s tank was a federal agent. No wonder the police hadn’t been able to identify him in any database. He was probably deep undercover, his identity carefully hidden. And no wonder Major Holly Voges had been so eager to shut down the SBPD’s investigation.

  But like every other revelation they’d come across in the investigation, this one seemed to raise far more questions than it answered. At least when Major Voges showed up at the Fortress, there was a murder to solve. Chubby Dead Fed had been following P’tol P’kah for weeks, maybe months. Why? What possible interest could Homeland Security, or some other, even more secret agency, have in a Vegas magician?

  “What else did he say?” Shawn asked.

  “Nothing,” she said bitterly. “He wouldn’t even tell me his name, just said to think of him as Uncle Sam. And that if I didn’t do exactly what he said, he would have David’s telecommunications firm shut down as a threat to national security and us both locked away as enemies of the state.”

  “Did he say which agency he worked for?” Shawn asked.

  “No, but he made it pretty clear it was something big, important, and unquestionable,” she said. “And that he had the authority to do whatever he wanted to me.”

  “What did you do?”

  “I was trying to figure that out, when P’tol P’kah descended from the ceiling and started growling,” she said. “The creep let go of me and ran out of the place; I don’t know why. And I went home, sprayed on an ex trathick layer of tan, and hoped he’d never come after me.”

  “That’s why you were so hostile when we knocked on your door,” Shawn said. “You thought we were government agents working for him.”

  “Yeah, right,” she said. “You I was scared of. Mr. Dead Cow.”

  “I’ll have you know I put a lot of thought into that story,” Shawn said. “I thought the punch line worked exactly as it was supposed to.”

  “Which is why
I broke down right then and there and told you everything you wanted to hear.”

  Gus could sense that this conversation was slipping away from where they needed it to go. Before Shawn could parry back at her point, he stepped in. “So when you saw the chubby guy floating dead in the tank, why didn’t you say anything?”

  “I was hoping it was all over. And I couldn’t afford for anyone to know who I really am. Because this,” she said, gesturing to her clean, bronze arms, “is who I really am these days. I couldn’t risk that just because I wanted to hang out at the Fortress for old times’ sake. Now please, I’ve told you everything I know. Let me go on with my interview. Let me go on with my life.”

  Shawn thought it over, then gave her a nod. She scurried through the parking lot to the clubhouse, spraying her arm with a mist of tan goo as she went.

  “That was an awful lot of time to get us exactly nowhere,” Gus said.

  “Really?” Shawn said. “We get the piece of information that’s going to crack this case wide open, and you say we’re nowhere?”

  “Which piece of information is that?” Gus said as he started back toward the Echo. “The name of the dead guy? Oh, right, we didn’t get it. The agency he worked for? The reason he was following P’tol P’kah?”

  “We know he worked for the federal government and that he suggested strongly he was in Homeland Security,” Shawn said. “Which sounds an awful lot like the thing Major Holly Voges told Jules and Lassie. Maybe whatever they do is what this case is really all about.”

  Gus froze with his hand on the car door handle. “You think P’tol P’kah really is a terrorist?”

  “Whose secret plot is to destroy America by entertaining us all to death?”

  “Then what?” Gus said.

  “Remember the basic rule to all magic?”

  “That the reason you can never figure out the secret to a trick is because it’s so obvious,” Gus said. “You’ve only mentioned it about six thousand times.”

  “We saw P’rupert P’upkin dissolve in a tank of water,” Shawn said with a hint of triumph in his voice. “What is the simplest possible explanation of that trick?”